• Skip to main navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to Footer
  • Navigate Novartis
    • Patients
    • Healthcare Professionals
    • Media
    • Investors
    • Partners
    • ESG
    • Job Seekers
    • Clinical Trials
  • Coronavirus
  • Global
    • Novartis site directory
Novartis logo: a global healthcare company
  • Our Company
    • Our Leadership
      • Board of Directors
      • Executive Committee of Novartis
    • Our Approach
      • Strategy
      • Corporate Responsibility
      • Diversity & Inclusion
      • Partnering
      • People and Culture
    • Our Business
      • Global Product Portfolio
      • Innovative Medicines
      • Novartis Pharmaceuticals
      • Novartis Gene Therapies
      • Novartis Oncology
      • Sandoz
    • Media
      • Newsroom
      • News Archive
      • Multimedia Resources
      • Subscribe to Updates
    • Investors
      • Event Calendar
      • Financial Data
      • Share Data & Analysis
      • Shareholder Information
      • Environmental, Social & Governance
  • Our Focus
    • Disease Areas
      • Cancer
      • Cardiovascular, Renal & Metabolism
      • Immunology & Dermatology
      • Ophthalmology
      • Neuroscience
      • Respiratory
    • Platforms and Technology
      • Data and Digital
      • Cell & Gene Therapy
    • Novartis Stories
      • Discovery
      • From Our Labs
      • Access to Healthcare
      • Patient Perspectives
      • People and Culture
      • Live Magazine
  • Our Impact
    • Building Trust with Society
      • Corporate Responsibility
      • Ethical Standards
      • Access
      • Environmental Sustainability
    • Global Health
      • Malaria
      • Sickle Cell Disease
      • Chagas disease
      • Leprosy
      • Novartis Foundation
    • ESG Performance and Reporting
      • Materiality
      • Environment, Social and Governance
      • Transparency and Disclosures
      • Positions on Key Topics
      • Statements on Key Issues
  • Our Science
    • Research & Early Development
      • Novartis Institutes for BioMedical Research
      • Research Disease Areas
      • Postdoc Program
      • Open Source Science
    • Drug Development at Novartis
      • Novartis Pipeline
      • Clinical Trials
      • Translational Medicine
      • Global Product Portfolio
    • Science Stories
      • Discovery
      • From Our Labs
  • Careers
    • Your Career
      • Global Career Search
      • Teams and Skills
      • Gene Therapies Careers
    • Working at Novartis
      • Diversity & Inclusion
      • Corporate Responsibility
    • Career Programs
      • Our Career Programs
      • Students and Scholars
      • Novartis Quantitative Sciences Hackathon
Search
Clinical trials make a move toward mice
  • TwitterTweet
  • FacebookShare
  • Share
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Email
    • Whatsapp
  • Jump to Comments
Stories/Discovery

Clinical trials make a move toward mice

By growing human tumors in mice, NIBR develops a unique system that seeks to mimic clinical trials of cancer drugs

By
Nicole Davis
Oct 19, 2015

Foretelling the future is often the stuff of science fiction but for a team of scientists at the Novartis Institutes for BioMedical Research (NIBR), it’s their end goal. Led by Juliet Williams, Director of Oncology Pharmacology, and Bill Sellers, Global Head of Oncology, the team has developed a unique system to help predict how cancer drugs might fare well before they enter clinical testing: Are they effective? What types of cancers do they target? Which patients are most likely to benefit from them?

To answer these questions, the team took tumor fragments isolated directly from cancer patients and grew them in mice. Unlike traditional cell line models, this tissue has never touched plastic culture dishes. When scaled across hundreds of patients with many different types of cancer, the approach resembles a kind of clinical trial — but one conducted in mice, not humans.  A paper describing this approach appears online in Nature Medicine on October 19.

“This really mirrors a clinical trial,” says Williams. “Typically, you have a person with her own unique tumor and that person gets one dose or one regimen of a drug or combination of drugs. In this case, it’s not a person — it’s a mouse bearing a human tumor.”

A key strength of this approach flows from the fact that patients’ cancer cells never touch a laboratory dish. The mere act of growing tumors on plastic can change their inherent properties, causing some cells to die off and others to rapidly proliferate — leaving behind a caricature of the original tumor, not a genuine replica.  

In contrast, implanting tumors in mice, by creating what is known as patient-derived tumor xenograft (PDX) mice, can more faithfully capture the complex biology of human cancers. Since not all tumors are equivalent — the broken genes that drive one person’s lung cancer are different from those that drive another’s, for example — the method can also be appropriately scaled to represent the genetic diversity that exists among various cancer types. 

“PDX mice are so powerful because they can capture the genetic heterogeneity that exists within one patient’s tumor and across many patients’ tumors,” says Hui Gao, first author of the study and a Senior Investigator in Oncology at NIBR. “That combination holds enormous promise for our ability to predict up front which drugs might help which patients.”  

chart-update
NIBR researchers created a vast compendium of patient-derived tumor xenograft mice, also called PDX mice, which can capture the complex biology of human tumors more faithfully than other approaches. This compendium includes tumors from hundreds of patients and more than 15 different tissues in the body. Chart courtesy of Nature Medicine.

By harnessing this powerful method, Williams, Gao and their colleagues created a compendium of roughly 900 different PDX models spanning major solid tumor types in adult patients. To facilitate the use of these models for testing large numbers of compounds, they first wanted to know if a one mouse, one tumor, one treatment approach would be feasible. It turns out this 1x1x1 method yields highly reproducible results, making it a practical approach to follow as they scaled up their tests. Another key advantage of this “PDX mouse clinical trial” is that tumors from one patient can be implanted in multiple mice, allowing subsequent tests against various different cancer drugs.

To determine how this mouse clinical trial stacks up against those done in humans, Williams, Gao, and their colleagues assembled a pharmaceutical toolkit comprised of more than 60 different anti-cancer treatment regimens. These included both single agents as well as drug combinations. They also included candidate drugs now undergoing clinical testing, compounds still undergoing pharmaceutical development, and therapies now considered a standard of clinical care. They tested this pharmacopeia against more than 250 PDX mouse models, using the 1x1x1 approach.  

Remarkably, the mouse clinical trial confirmed several things that were already known from previous human clinical trials. For example, among mice carrying melanoma tumors, roughly 30% of those with mutations in a key gene, called B-RAF, failed to respond to drugs targeting those gene mutations. This is similar to what has been observed in human studies.

The mouse trial also revealed its capacity for uncovering novel insights, such as potential new combinations of cancer drugs — like the addition of a drug known as a CDK4/6 inhibitor to the B-RAF inhibitor treatment often given to melanoma patients. This combination had not been previously thought to be effective, but the new study suggests it could be.  

“We’re encouraged by the data,” says Lilli Petruzzelli, who heads the global team responsible for designing human oncology trials at NIBR. “These early results have helped us design more focused combination clinical studies that have the potential to bring benefit to patients.”

Career opportunities

Find career opportunities in Oncology and Immuno-oncology research at Novartis.

Visit our career search page to learn more.


Main image: adventtr/iStock

Shareline

By growing human tumors in mice, NIBR develops a unique system that seeks to mimic clinical trials of cancer drugs
Tweet Tweetpopo
Tags: 
Novartis Institutes for BioMedical Research, Reimagine Medicine, Scientific Research, Clinical Research, Clinical Trials, Gene Testing

Nicole Davis

Nicole Davis

is a freelance writer and communications consultant specializing in biomedicine and biotechnology. She has worked in science communications for nearly a decade and earned her PhD in genetics at Harvard University. 

    • TwitterTweet
    • FacebookShare
    • Share
      • Twitter
      • Facebook
      • LinkedIn
      • Email
      • Whatsapp
    • Jump to Comments
  • Print
  • Save

Novartis Stories

View all

A kidney patient is smiling at the camera
Discovery

New hope for treating inflammatory diseases of the kidney

2D rendering of kidneys
Discovery

Predictive analytics could bring medicines to patients faster

Discovery

Making Possible: Stepping toward a future with cell and gene therapy

You are here

  1. Home ›
  2. Stories ›
  3. Discovery

Novartis Global

  • Navigate Novartis

    • Patients & Caregivers
    • Healthcare Professionals
    • Investors
    • Media
    • Society & ESG
    • Partners
  • Contact Us

    • Global Contacts
    • Office Locations
    • For Investors
    • For Media
  • About Novartis

    • Our Company
    • Our Focus
    • Our Impact
    • Our Science
    • Our Stories
  • Our Portfolio

    • Global Product Portfolio
    • Global Clinical Pipeline
  • Careers

    • Career Search

Connect with Novartis

  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • youtube
  • facebook
  • instagram
Novartis Site Directory
© 2021 Novartis AG
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Site Map
  • Cookie Settings

This site is intended for a global audience.