• Skip to main navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to Footer
  • Navigate Novartis
    • Patients
    • Healthcare Professionals
    • Media
    • Investors
    • Partners
    • ESG
    • Job Seekers
    • Clinical Trials
  • Coronavirus
  • Global
    • Novartis site directory
Novartis logo: a global healthcare company
  • Our Company
    • Our Leadership
      • Board of Directors
      • Executive Committee of Novartis
    • Our Approach
      • Strategy
      • Corporate Responsibility
      • Diversity & Inclusion
      • Partnering
      • People and Culture
    • Our Business
      • Global Product Portfolio
      • Innovative Medicines
      • Novartis Pharmaceuticals
      • Novartis Gene Therapies
      • Novartis Oncology
      • Sandoz
    • Media
      • Newsroom
      • News Archive
      • Multimedia Resources
      • Subscribe to Updates
    • Investors
      • Event Calendar
      • Financial Data
      • Share Data & Analysis
      • Shareholder Information
      • Environmental, Social & Governance
  • Our Focus
    • Disease Areas
      • Cancer
      • Cardiovascular, Renal and Metabolic Medicine
      • Immunology & Dermatology
      • Ophthalmology
      • Neuroscience
      • Respiratory
    • Platforms and Technology
      • Data and Digital
      • Cell & Gene Therapy
    • Novartis Stories
      • Discovery
      • From Our Labs
      • Access to Healthcare
      • Patient Perspectives
      • People and Culture
      • Live Magazine
  • Our Impact
    • Building Trust with Society
      • Corporate Responsibility
      • Ethical Standards
      • Access
      • Environmental Sustainability
    • Global Health
      • Malaria
      • Sickle Cell Disease
      • Chagas disease
      • Leprosy
      • Novartis Foundation
    • ESG Performance and Reporting
      • Materiality Assessment
      • Environmental, Social and Governance
      • Transparency and Disclosures
      • Positions on Key Topics
      • Statements on Key Issues
  • Our Science
    • Research & Early Development
      • Novartis Institutes for BioMedical Research
      • Research Disease Areas
      • Postdoc Program
      • Open Source Science
    • Drug Development at Novartis
      • Novartis Pipeline
      • Clinical Trials
      • Translational Medicine
      • Global Product Portfolio
    • Science Stories
      • Discovery
      • From Our Labs
  • Careers
    • Your Career
      • Global Career Search
      • Teams and Skills
      • Gene Therapies Careers
    • Working at Novartis
      • Diversity & Inclusion
      • People and Culture
      • Corporate Responsibility
    • Career Programs
      • Our Career Programs
      • Students and Scholars
      • Novartis Quantitative Sciences Hackathon
Search
  • TwitterTweet
  • FacebookShare
  • Share
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Email
    • Whatsapp
  • Jump to Comments
Stories/From Our Labs

Five things to look for in a scientific mentor

By
Anastacia Berzat
Jul 22, 2015
Five things to look for in a scientific mentor - hero image

The late Alan Hall and NIBR’s Anastacia Berzat (at right) during her five-year postdoc in Hall’s lab at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center (MSKCC). Courtesy of MSKCC.

Five things to look for in a scientific mentor

The late Alan Hall was a model mentor who supported the development of many researchers’ careers

Five things to look for in a scientific mentor

NIBR’s mentorship leader Anastacia Berzat met Alan Hall during a research conference in 2003.

Five things to look for in a scientific mentor

NIBR’s Anastacia Berzat will always remember how Alan Hall signed (bottom right) her data slide with “flourish and good humor.”

Five things to look for in a scientific mentor

Anastacia Berzat congratulates an emerging scholar during a 2014 ceremony at NIBR in Cambridge, MA. Image by PJ Kaszas.

Have you ever wondered how to identify the best scientific mentor for yourself?  Or perhaps, you wonder how to be a great mentor or mentee?

These are questions I explore as lead of research and mentoring training programs for emerging scientists. I often refer to my own seminal mentoring relationship during my five-year postdoc with the late Alan Hall, PhD, Cell Biology Program Chair, at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center in New York City. His lab was very diverse and welcomed people from many countries and regions of the United States. We all had different approaches to addressing our scientific questions, which made for very engaging discussions and collaborations. Hall celebrated everything. We were always acknowledged, whether it was for publications and grants, graduations and new jobs, or birthdays and cultural differences.

Following are five key mentoring behaviors Hall exhibited well and that you should look for in a mentor:

Acceptance and confirmation

When I first met Hall in 2003, he quickly showed his great capacity for acceptance and confirmation. I was a third-year PhD graduate student at a research conference in Colorado.   I was already a fan of his work; he discovered key intracellular mechanisms driving cell shape and motility. I wanted to impress him with my scientific poster and capture his autograph. I saw him walking to dinner with four other well-known scientists and introduced myself. Always gracious, he invited me to join them for dinner. The result was an engaging, lively scientific discussion where my opinions were equally valued.  I asked for his coveted autograph on my data slide, which he signed with flourish and good humor.

Listening and explicit support

It’s a common mistake for mentors and mentees to assume knowledge of what the other needs. Hall, conversely, engaged in reciprocal exchanges on expectations, learning styles, scientific direction, and career needs.  I feel like we learned a lot from each other. For example, I wanted to write a review chapter on cellular migration to strengthen my knowledge in the field, establish my credibility, and identify potential scientific areas to pursue further.  I asked Hall for recommendations on how I might achieve this.  First, he listened. Then, he offered a review invitation from the European Molecular Biology Organization (EMBO) Journal he had recently received as an opportunity for me.   Additionally, he met with me to discuss the review structure, provide edits, and give feedback on the illustrative diagrams.   He even suggested classical papers that might help to orient me in the field.

Open-door approach

I never needed an appointment to see Hall and his office door was always open. I could walk in at any time and he would stop working or end phone calls just to speak with me. This behavior was impressive given that he was the Chair of the department. This pattern continued even after I left the lab for my position at the Novartis Institutes for BioMedical Research (NIBR), the research unit of the Swiss pharmaceutical company Novartis. I would stop by the lab during visits to New York City and our conversations transitioned from discussion about scientific theories and collaborative opportunities for my project to the challenges of leading a research lab, managing a department, and my perspective on career possibilities for postdocs outside academia.

Honest feedback

Clear, authentic, and constructive communication is a hallmark of strong mentoring relationships and one of Hall’s many strengths. During my postdoc, I was offered a part-time program management internship at a different institution. Hall readily agreed that I should pursue this opportunity as long as the experience didn’t adversely impact my research progression. I pursued it and it didn’t interfere with my work. Later, I applied for and received an international postdoc fellowship to do research in Italy. While he supported this endeavor, Hall shared his concerns on whether this was the best career move given my interests in scientific programming. He also shared that this might be a great opportunity if I was interested in gaining global experience and cultural intelligence.

Independence and trust

Hall didn’t try to clone himself in his trainees. His motto was always that we create our own future and scientific successes, and that his lab was a foundation on which we could flourish.  There was an implied trust in our ability to drive our own projects. If we needed a collaboration and we felt we were unable to initiate it ourselves, he would step in.  If we had a specific research approach or direction we wanted to try, he helped to foster it by providing critical feedback and opportunities by which we could explore it.  He never stood in the way of our thinking and he didn’t write our grants and papers either.  These were all our own ideas.

Hall mentored and inspired many graduate students, postdocs, and junior faculty and his mentoring legacy lives on through us.  At Novartis, four of us are former Alan Hall postdocs: Aron Jaffe (Cambridge), Volker Stucke (Basel), Xiaojian Xu (Shanghai), and myself (Cambridge).

To learn more about mentoring relationships, research training programs at NIBR, and other opportunities, follow me @acberzat on Twitter. I will be tweeting live at the upcoming Leadership Alliance National Symposium—which runs July 24-26—from the @NovartisScience handle.

Tags: 
Biomedical Research, Novartis Institutes for BioMedical Research, Postdoc Program, Scientific Research

Anastacia Berzat

Anastacia Berzat

leads research training programs for emerging scientists and their mentors at the Novartis Institutes for BioMedical Research.  She is committed to helping people overcome barriers and unlock their full potential.  In her spare time, she enjoys good food, loves fashion, travels often and pampers her fluffy Shih Tzu.

    • TwitterTweet
    • FacebookShare
    • Share
      • Twitter
      • Facebook
      • LinkedIn
      • Email
      • Whatsapp
    • Jump to Comments
  • Print
  • Save

Novartis Stories

View all

Coronavirus
From Our Labs

A visual tour of scientific strategies for combating coronavirus

Wendi Yajnik, Global Head of Academic Partnerships and External Innovation for research
From Our Labs

Advancing medicine through collaboration

Special instrument controlled by a production associate
From Our Labs

Turning the power of nuclear technology into a medical force

You are here

  1. Home ›
  2. Stories ›
  3. From Our Labs

Novartis Global

  • Navigate Novartis

    • Patients & Caregivers
    • Healthcare Professionals
    • Investors
    • Media
    • Society & ESG
    • Partners
  • Contact Us

    • Global Contacts
    • Office Locations
    • For Investors
    • For Media
  • About Novartis

    • Our Company
    • Our Focus
    • Our Impact
    • Our Science
    • Our Stories
  • Our Portfolio

    • Global Product Portfolio
    • Global Clinical Pipeline
  • Careers

    • Career Search

Connect with Novartis

  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • youtube
  • facebook
  • instagram
Novartis Site Directory
© 2021 Novartis AG
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Site Map
  • Cookie Settings

This site is intended for a global audience.